Navigating Healthcare Cost Management: A Balanced Approach for Insurance Brokers & Agencies
December 17, 2024
By: Erick Kuhni
erick@benefitsculptor.com
In the ever-complex world of healthcare, brokers and agencies stand at a crossroads between rising costs and increasing demands for quality care. The challenge? Delivering solutions that don’t just cut corners but genuinely balance affordability with access. This isn’t just a numbers game—strategic healthcare is an art form requiring nuance, foresight, and a little bold thinking.
Insurance is the foundation that supports businesses and the livelihoods of their employees. And when it comes to healthcare, brokers help make or break that foundation.
The Equation Behind Healthcare Costs: Price vs. Volume
At the heart of healthcare economics lies a simple yet profound formula:
COST = UNIT_PRICE x UNIT_VOLUME
This is not just a mathematical equation, it’s also a mirror reflecting how care is consumed and priced. On one side, we have the unit price—the cost of each service. On the other, unit volume—the number of services rendered. Effective cost management requires a delicate balance between these two levers.
Reduce unit price without curbing volume? Costs can spiral if utilization rises unchecked. Lower volume but allow unit prices to inflate? The budget may stabilize in the short term but at the expense of employee health, potentially triggering long-term cost spikes.
Hypothetical Scenario: Telehealth as a Strategic Healthcare Move
Take, for example, a manufacturing company struggling with rising healthcare premiums. Their employees frequently visited urgent care clinics for minor ailments, driving up both volume and costs. The company introduces a telehealth solution, cutting the unit price of routine consultations. Over time, the convenience of virtual care reduces unnecessary clinic visits, and the company sees a 20% reduction in overall healthcare cost management.
Telehealth is the type of strategic pivot that prioritizes access and efficiency without sacrificing care quality.
Four Scenarios for Healthcare Cost Management
1. Increasing unit price and unit volume
Sustainable employee benefits become unmanageable when both the cost per service and the number of services used rise. This is the nightmare scenario: the healthcare equivalent of letting weeds overrun a garden. Furthermore, it often signals overutilization—services that may be redundant, unnecessary, or even harmful.
Hypothetical Example: A Retailer Tackles Overuse
Picture a large retail chain where employees routinely seek multiple diagnostic tests for the same condition. The broker identifies this trend through data analytics and works with the company to standardize protocols. By encouraging second-opinion telehealth consultations before tests, they reduced redundant services, trimming costs while ensuring employee health needs were met.
2. Rising unit price with falling unit volume
On paper, fewer services might seem like a win—until you consider the rising cost per service. This is often driven by high-tech advancements, specialist care, or inefficiencies in the system. The real risk? Employees skipping essential care due to inflated out-of-pocket expenses.
Hypothetical Example: Construction Workers Avoiding Care
A construction firm faces a decline in preventive care visits due to rising specialist fees. Employees opt to "tough it out," only seeking care when issues become critical—and costly. In response, the broker devises a direct-primary-care plan, offering unlimited access to primary care for a flat fee. This strategy re-engages employees with preventive care, reducing long-term claims and restoring a balance between costs and access.
3. Lowering unit price with increasing unit volume
Lowering the cost of services while utilization climbs can create efficiencies but also raise red flags about overuse. Is the increased demand driven by genuine need, or is it a case of "more because it’s cheap?”
Hypothetical Example: Hospitality and Overused Physical Therapy
In the hospitality sector, a hotel chain noticed an uptick in physical therapy claims after negotiating lower rates. While unit prices dropped, claims for minor aches soared. Employees treated therapy as a perk rather than a necessity. The broker worked with HR to introduce ergonomic training and education about appropriate care. Claims normalized, and costs aligned with actual needs.
4. Decreasing both unit price and unit volume
The holy grail of healthcare management is reducing both price and volume simultaneously—a rare but achievable outcome. This balance often signals a proactive approach to wellness and prevention.
Hypothetical Example: Financial Services Finds the Sweet Spot for Sustainable Employee Benefits
A financial firm implemented an ambitious wellness program, including regular biometric screenings, on-site fitness classes, and healthy food options in the cafeteria. Over three years, claims decreased as employees became healthier, and the firm renegotiated lower rates with providers due to the reduced risk profile. This was a textbook case of how brokers can turn wellness investments into tangible savings.
Striking a Balance for True Healthcare Sustainability
In the end, sustainability in healthcare isn’t about slashing costs to the bone—it’s about building systems that work for everyone, now and in the future. It’s about recognizing that health is an investment, not an expense.
The Broker’s Role as a Strategic Healthcare Advisor
This is where brokers shine. The most successful brokers aren’t mere middlemen—they’re strategists, advocates, and sometimes even trailblazers. We don’t just analyze spreadsheets; we see the people behind the numbers. Balancing costs and care means creating solutions that align with company values while fostering healthier, more productive employees.
Hypothetical Closing Example: The Long Game for Small Businesses
Consider a boutique law firm with limited resources but a commitment to employee well-being. Their broker proposed a high-deductible health plan paired with an HSA and access to a concierge care service. Employees appreciated the personalized support, and the firm experienced lower claims and higher retention rates. This wasn’t just a healthcare plan—it was a competitive advantage.
***
In a world where healthcare cost management is a universal concern, finding the balance between affordability and accessibility is more than a professional obligation—it’s a moral one. By embracing innovative strategies and forward-thinking solutions, brokers can be the architects of a healthier, more sustainable employee benefits future for businesses and employees alike.
